[Ring'Em Up]

Here in Johnson Co Cal Ripken/Babe Ruth, each manager in their division has one vote, 4 league directors(vice-pres, player agent, division director, and director of umpires) each have a vote, and then the league president is the tie-breaker vote in any case needed. All divisions have an even number of teams (4 10under softball coach pitch teams, 6 12under softball, 2 16under softball, 10 8under coach pitch baseball, 6 10under baseball, 4 12under baseball, and 2 15under baseball) that play in All-star tourneys, but it is still rare that a tie-breaker is needed.
Each person turns in a ballot with their top 12. Votes are tallied and top 12 vote getters are announced as the All stars, with the next 2 as alternates. The manager of the team winning the regular season title is awarded the All star team, and he makes his picks for 2 coaches from anyone else in that division.