Poll: Who Wins
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
St. X
15.38%
Trinity
84.62%
* You voted for this item.

  Thread Closed
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
St. Xavier vs. Trinity (6A STATE CHAMPIONSHIP)
#35
Pulp Fiction Wrote:The most populous areas doesn't equal the most interest.

Let's look at some evidence behind by thinking........

2007 - Trinity
2008 - Trinity
2009 - St. X
2010 - Trinity
2011 - Trinity
2012 - Trinity
2013 - Scott County
2014 - Trinity
2015 - Male
2016 - Trinity
2017 - T or X ???

This is the eleventh season that 6A has been added, only four schools have won the state title. Three teams from Louisville and Scott County, this year either T or X will win it.
We all know that T and X are two of the best current and traditional football powers in the state. With the number of male students they have and the resources they have, they should be.


We haven't seen an Underdog story in 6A or the old 4A class since the 1991 GRC team that beat St. X in the finals... if you can consider that an upset.

From 2006-1997, 4A was won by either T, X or Male.

2006 - Trinity
2005 - Trinity
2004 - St. X
2003 - Trinity
2002 - Trinity
2001 - Trinity
2000 - Male
1999 - St. X
1998 - Male
1997 - St. X

In the past twenty one consecutive seasons, only FOUR teams have won the 6A or old 4A state title. T, X, Male & Scott County.... Twenty of the twenty one state titles have been claimed by a team from Jefferson County. Seventeen of the twenty one being claimed by a Louisville area, Catholic school.



Nobody can tell me that 6A or the old 4A class has had any type of true underdog or Cinderella type story in the past twenty one seasons. Where's the drama or excitement about a class that hasn't been competitive except for four teams in twenty one years? For the very small number of schools that have a legitimate shot at winning 6A, then yes, I would say they do 'care' about 6A, but that number is very small in comparison to those that don't. It wouldn't be right for me to say that the other twenty nine teams in 6A that aren't T, X, Male or Scott County don't give their 110% in practice and in games or they don't strive to win the state title each season. If 6A saw a state championship game that had two teams that had never won 6A or any other football state title, then I would have to say that 6A would get more interest than when T & X play each other.

The only way a game can be interesting is if it's an underdog story?

I'm going to have to disagree with you there. Rivalries add a great spice to a finals game and there is no biggest rivalry in the state than these two. Plus, as I mentioned earlier, they are two of the best teams in the state. Top level football will be on display.

Your post sounds a lot more like a regional gripe, 'if someone from outside Louisville doesn't win why should I care?', than any actual reason for why the game wouldn't be interesting.

Shrug, no team from Louisville has ever won 1A, but I don't downtalk that class.
Messages In This Thread
St. Xavier vs. Trinity (6A STATE CHAMPIONSHIP) - by CarzyRock - 11-26-2017, 07:47 PM

Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: