[WideRight05]

Belfry has 6 Titles and 7 Runner-Ups.
CovCath has 7 titles and 1 Runner-Up.
NewCath has 5 Titles and 6 Runner-Ups.

Belfry and NewCath would have substantially more Regional Titles than CovCath as well.

To be honest, CovCath's resume is actually considerbaly less impressive than NewCath's at second glance, let alone Belfry's.

The only argument you can make for CovCath to be above either is the "what if" game since Highlands has always been in their path all these years. Obviously that doesn't hold water when judging things based off statistical proof. Even then, both NewCath and Belfry have not been lacking for years that they lost to the eventual State Champ themselves in the playoffs.

It's also worth noting Belfry is 5-1 vs. NCC head to head. Belfry and CovCath have not met.

It wouldn't be a what-if game, it's a fact game. Many years CovCath or Johnson Central would be loaded only to not make it through a highlands team that usually was solid enough to pull an upset over a major Ohio school such as Cincinnati St. X. CovCath and Belfry aren't in the same league. Maybe NCC - I'm glad at least Belfry can say they are leading them all-time. But other than that, CovCath is substantially ahead of Belfry because there are many years they would have won state had it not been for Highlands. The only school that might have stopped them is Johnson Central.