[Redneck]

I'll be the odd one out. No, I don't think he should get it. I watched the game on webcast the other night. His stats are impressive but he seems to be more of a product of the system much like Tim Couch was in the Hal Mumme days.

To me Guy and Boyd are both better football players. Stats don't always tell the whole story.

???? Tim Couch woulda been a **** of an NFL QB if he woulda went somewhere other than the Browns. It ain't his fault he had recievers who couldn't catch those bulletts he was throwin. Not only that he had to run for his life every game.

Guy and Boyd are both great players but how do you overlook this guy when he has led his team (who has no football tradition at all) to the state championship. You are right, numbers don't always mean everything, but in this case I gotta say it does. I do however respect your opinion.